More info

Complaint routes against a health insurer: who reviews the notice

If your health insurer calculates the contribution incorrectly, the objection to the insurer comes first. The supervisory authority and the social court follow, depending on the dispute.
Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Contents

If your health insurer calculates your contribution incorrectly, you first lodge an objection with the insurer itself. Only afterwards do the supervisory authority or the social court come into question, and which route fits depends on the subject of the dispute.

Author: Academycon editorial team. Published: 2 November 2026. Last reviewed: 2 November 2026.

Short answer: First you lodge a written objection with the health insurer, because it reviews the notice itself. After that, the supervisory authority is open for complaints about the insurer’s conduct, and the social court for a judicial review of the notice. The deadline that applies is stated in the notice. Last updated: November 2026.

Academycon, an insurance broker in Göttingen focused on students, trainee civil servants and graduates, explains which body is responsible for what and the order in which you should proceed. German terms appear in brackets where they matter.

The key points in brief

  • The first step is an objection (Widerspruch) to the health insurer, which reviews the notice itself.
  • The supervisory authority (Aufsicht) checks the conduct of the insurer, but it does not decide your claim as a court would.
  • The social court (Sozialgericht) is competent if you want the notice reviewed by a court.
  • Deadlines run from the date the notice is delivered, so record the date on which you received it.
  • For simple calculation errors, a written query often helps before you file a formal objection.

Who can I turn to if my health insurer calculates my contribution incorrectly?

First to the health insurer itself, with a written objection against the contribution notice. The insurer then reviews the calculation and can amend the notice or reject the objection. Against a rejection, you can bring an action. For complaints about the conduct or responsiveness of the insurer, the supervisory authority is available in addition.

Step 1: objection to the health insurer

The objection must reach the insurer in writing and identify the notice clearly. Briefly explain what you consider wrong, for example the contribution basis, the period or the contribution rate. If you refer to your income, enclose copies of the evidence. Keep the proof of receipt as well, because it shows when you acted.

Step 2: involve the supervisory authority

Supervision depends on the type of insurer. The Federal Office for Social Security (Bundesamt für Soziale Sicherung) supervises federal health insurers, while regional insurers are supervised by the competent state authority. The authority checks whether the insurer acts lawfully. It does not decide, as a court would, on your entitlement to a particular contribution amount. Ask your insurer which body is responsible for it.

Step 3: social court

If the objection is rejected, an action before the social court can review the notice. The court decides on the lawfulness of the assessment, for example the contribution basis, the period and the contribution rate. Such proceedings take time, but they produce an independent decision on the disputed question.

Which route fits which problem?

ProblemFirst stepWho decides or reviews
Contribution basis or income assessed incorrectlyObjection to the health insurerHealth insurer, then social court
Contribution rate or period wrongObjection to the health insurerHealth insurer, then social court
Delayed or inappropriate handlingWritten complaint to the insurerSupervisory authority reviews the conduct
Several errors or no reply from the insurerContact the supervisory authority after consultingSupervisory authority, and a court in a dispute

Status and source: last updated November 2026. Responsibilities follow the Social Code Book V and the Social Courts Act (Sozialgerichtsgesetz, in German). Supervision over federal health insurers lies with the Federal Office for Social Security.

When a complaint makes sense

A complaint to the supervisory authority makes sense when the insurer does not respond, lets deadlines pass or refuses information. It does not, however, replace an objection. If you only want to criticise the conduct of an employee, you do not get a new contribution calculation as a result. For the amount of the contribution, the objection remains the right route.

The reverse also holds: an objection against the notice only affects the disputed assessment. If you were also inadequately informed, record this in a separate letter so that the process stays traceable.

Common mistakes in an objection

Many objections fail not on the substance but on formalities. Often the objection lacks a clear reference to the notice, or it disputes everything without saying which value is wrong. State which entry you consider incorrect and enclose the evidence. A phone agreement does not replace the written objection, however helpful it may be.

  • The objection does not name the date or reference of the notice
  • The reasoning stays general and does not identify a concrete error
  • Evidence is missing although the objection relies on income
  • The deadline is missed because receipt was not documented

Which documents should I put together?

  • The notice with its date and the date on which you received it
  • Income evidence or other information on which your objection relies
  • The earlier correspondence with the insurer, including notes of phone calls
  • A copy of your objection with the proof of receipt

Frequently asked questions

Who is the supervisory authority?

The supervisory authority depends on the legal form of your health insurer. The Federal Office for Social Security supervises federal health insurers, while regional insurers are supervised by the competent state authority. Your insurer will name the responsible body on request.

When is a social court case worthwhile?

It is mainly worthwhile for clear legal questions or larger amounts, when the insurer keeps its calculation after your objection. The objection should be exhausted first. Whether the effort pays off depends on the subject of the dispute.

Do I need a lawyer for this?

No, proceedings before the social court generally do not require legal representation. For difficult questions, advice from a body specialised in social law can help. For insured persons, proceedings are usually possible without court fees.

Do I have to keep paying the contribution during the objection?

Clarify this with your insurer before you stop any payments. If you do not pay, you risk reminders and late-payment surcharges. A written statement from the insurer gives you certainty for your planning.

What to do next

  1. Check the notice for the contribution basis, the period and the contribution rate, and note the deadline.
  2. File a written objection with the health insurer and keep the proof of receipt.
  3. Ask which supervisory authority is responsible if the insurer’s conduct is the problem.
  4. After the decision, check whether an action before the social court makes sense. For a personal assessment, Academycon can be reached via https://academycon.de/so-arbeiten-wir/ (in German).

Related guides

About Academycon

Academycon GmbH is an insurance broker based in Göttingen. The editorial team publishes guides on health insurance, study financing and protection for students, trainee civil servants and graduates.

Sources:

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Gatekeeper model over 30: what it means for costs and fund choice

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Requesting a contribution certificate from your health insurer

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Fund merger or closure: what happens to contribution and membership