More info

Switching health insurer with contribution arrears: open claims

You can generally switch statutory health insurer while still owing contributions, but the arrears stay with your old fund. This guide explains section 175 SGB V and the steps to take first.
Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Contents

You can generally switch your statutory health insurer while contributions are still outstanding, but the debt does not disappear with the switch. Anyone planning to change funds with arrears should know the order of steps: first the legal position, then the clarification with the old fund, then the termination. Academycon, an insurance broker in Göttingen focused on students, trainee civil servants and graduates, explains which rules apply and where the pitfalls are.

Author: Academycon editorial team. Published: 2 November 2026. Last reviewed: 2 November 2026.

Short answer: Yes, you can generally switch your statutory health insurance even if you still owe contributions. The right to choose a fund is governed by section 175 of the Social Code Book V (§ 175 SGB V), and that section names no bar based on unpaid contributions. The outstanding claim stays with your old fund and has to be settled there. Last updated: November 2026.

What are the most important points?

  • The right to choose a health fund is governed by section 175 SGB V (in German), which names no bar for unpaid contributions.
  • A switch does not cancel the outstanding claim. It remains with your old fund.
  • The old fund confirms the end of membership within two weeks.
  • As a rule a binding period of twelve months applies, which you should know in advance.
  • Before you terminate, a written agreement on payment or instalments is worth having.

Can I switch my health insurer if I still owe contributions?

The right to choose is set out in section 175 SGB V (in German). Under the law, a member may choose a fund once the conditions are met. The fund you choose may not refuse membership or make the choice harder through incomplete advice. The arrears with the old fund are not named as a reason to refuse in this section.

This does not mean the matter is closed. The contributions are an obligation towards the old fund, and they stay with you until they are settled. If you plan a switch, first find out the exact state of the debt and then decide how to proceed. For the wider picture of costs as a student over 30, see the guide Krankenversicherung als Student über 30: Pflicht, Kosten und Wege (in German).

Do the debts remain after the switch?

Yes. A switch does not cancel the claim. The debt belongs to the earlier membership, and the new fund does not take it over automatically. How the claim is handled afterwards depends on the individual case, so clarify the position in writing with the old fund before you complete the switch.

It is also worth asking whether the old fund may restrict benefits while the arrears are open. The Social Code Book V, in particular section 16 SGB V (in German), and the statutes of the fund set out the rules. Ask the fund directly whether and from when this applies, so that you are not caught out.

How does the switch work formally?

The new fund notifies the old fund of the switch electronically. The old fund confirms the end of membership without delay and at the latest within two weeks (section 175 subsection 2 SGB V). The notification from the new fund replaces the termination. As a rule, a termination is possible for the end of the second calendar month after the month in which it is declared (section 175 subsection 4 SGB V).

SituationWhat then appliesWhat you can do
Outstanding contributions with the old fundThe claim remains in placeRequest the statement in writing and clarify it
New fund notifies the switchThe old fund is informed electronicallyCheck that the notification has arrived
Confirmation by the old fundWithin two weeks at the latestKeep the confirmation
Binding period of twelve monthsTermination only after the period endsAgree the timing with the new fund

Source and date: November 2026, section 175 SGB V (in German). The deadlines apply unless an exception such as the special termination right after an additional contribution increase applies.

Which steps help with arrears?

  • Ask the old fund for a current statement of the outstanding contributions and any surcharges.
  • Check whether the assessment is correct, above all the income basis it rests on.
  • Offer instalments before the fund sends a reminder.
  • Record every agreement in writing, including deferrals and payment plans.

Why an early clarification makes sense

The earlier you clarify the arrears, the more room you have. A reminder makes the situation tighter, because it can affect the benefits you receive. Anyone who agrees on a plan before the switch shows the old fund a willingness to pay, and the new fund sees an orderly process. For the cost side, the guide Krankenversicherung im Studium nach Alter: Kosten unter 25, 25 bis 29 und ab 30 (in German) gives the overview.

What if the old fund does not respond?

Sometimes an answer does not arrive, or the figures on the arrears do not match your records. Then a written record helps. Tell the fund which payments you made and enclose copies of the transfers. This gives you a basis if the claim is later disputed.

If clarification stays difficult, the responsible supervisory authority can also be involved. Date every step and keep all replies. For larger amounts, or if benefits are refused, advice from a body familiar with social insurance law is advisable.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to pay the arrears first?

Section 175 SGB V does not link the switch to a payment. The debt remains, however, so an agreement before the switch is sensible. Whether a partial payment is enough is something you clarify with the old fund.

Does the old fund lose my claim?

No. A switch does not cancel the claim. The old fund can pursue its claim as long as it is not settled.

Is the old fund informed about the switch?

Yes. The new fund notifies the switch electronically, and the old fund confirms the end of membership within two weeks.

Can an instalment plan prepare the switch?

Yes, that is often sensible. A written instalment plan makes the arrears transparent and eases coordination between the two funds.

What you should do now

  1. Ask your old fund for a current statement of contributions, surcharges and open claims.
  2. Check the contribution assessment and the income basis before you pay or negotiate.
  3. Agree instalments or a deferral in writing before you start the switch.
  4. Notify the switch only once the clarification is under way. For support with the process, see How Academycon works.

Related guides

About Academycon

Academycon GmbH is an insurance broker based in Göttingen. The editorial team publishes guides on health insurance, study financing and protection for students, trainee civil servants and graduates.

Sources: Section 175 SGB V, exercise of the right to choose (in German, gesetze-im-internet.de); Section 16 SGB V, suspension of benefits (in German, gesetze-im-internet.de).

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Gatekeeper model over 30: what it means for costs and fund choice

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Requesting a contribution certificate from your health insurer

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Fund merger or closure: what happens to contribution and membership