Spotting fake reviews means judging online ratings by where they come from, not by the average star score alone. If you read the stars before a purchase, a booking or a rental, you should know which patterns point to manipulated ratings and which duties companies have when they publish them. This guide shows how to recognise fabricated reviews and how to check a review page step by step.
Short answer: Fake online reviews show several warning signs at once: an unusually high share of five-star ratings within a short period, generic wording that does not mention the product, and profiles with no history beyond a few posts. Under section 5b (3) of the German Act against Unfair Competition (UWG), companies must disclose whether and how they make sure that reviews come from people who actually used or bought the product. Last updated: November 2026.
The most important points in brief
- Suspicious patterns in reviews are a stronger warning sign than the average score alone.
- An average of 4.6 stars from 40 ratings tells you more than 5.0 stars from three ratings.
- Under section 5b (3) UWG, companies must state how they make sure that reviews come from real buyers.
- Vouchers or discounts given for good ratings distort the picture, even though not every form of incentive is banned.
- Check the timeline, the profiles and the content before you trust the stars.
- A defect remains a defect even if the reviews were positive. Your rights from the purchase still apply.
What do fake reviews look like?
There is no reliable method that exposes every fabricated review. Several signals together are meaningful, though. The table below summarises the most common patterns and what you can do about each.
| Signal | Why it stands out | What you can do |
|---|---|---|
| Many reviews within a few days | Genuine customers usually arrive over months, while bursts suggest a coordinated campaign | Sort the reviews by date and look at the time windows |
| Only five-star or only one-star ratings | Genuine ratings usually spread more widely | Read the middle ratings and the critical texts on purpose |
| Generic praise | Texts name neither model, size nor period of use | Look for concrete details such as delivery time or build quality |
| Similar wording across several accounts | Templates are often reused | Compare several texts side by side |
| Profiles without any history | New accounts with no other activity often stand for one-off ratings | Check how old the account is and what else it has rated |
| Signs of a reward for the review | Discounts or gifts for good stars distort the result | Give the review less weight and consult other sources |
None of these signals proves a fake on its own. A new product starts with few ratings, and a satisfied buyer does not always write at length. What matters is the combination of several irregularities.
What does the law require from companies?
The rule is set out in section 5b of the German Act against Unfair Competition (UWG, wording retrieved from gesetze-im-internet.de on 2 November 2026). Under subsection 3, information about whether and how the trader ensures that published reviews come from consumers who actually used or bought the goods or services counts as material. Material means the information must not be left out where it could affect your decision. The provision implements the Omnibus Directive (EU) 2019/2161.
This does not oblige a shop to check every single review in advance. It does require the shop to explain how it works with real customers. If that information is missing, the presentation of its ratings may count as misleading. In case of doubt, courts decide whether a specific case falls under this rule. A provider’s notes on reviews often show whether only buyers may rate or whether it collects ratings without checking purchase records.
How do you check a review page step by step?
- Look at the distribution of stars, not only the average. Count how many ratings exist in total and how they spread across the scale.
- Sort by date. Clusters within a few days are a clear warning sign.
- Open three to five reviewer profiles. Check how old the account is and whether it has other ratings.
- Search for details. A text that describes size, use or experience with the product is more credible than a bare phrase.
- Read the provider’s statements. Does it explain how it makes sure that its reviews are authentic?
Why the number of ratings matters
An average is only as reliable as the number of votes behind it. This is easy to check with a simple calculation.
Assumption: A product has 40 ratings, 36 of them with five stars and four with one star. The average is then (36 × 5 + 4 × 1) / 40 = 4.6 stars.
Assumption: Another offer has three ratings, all with five stars. The average is 5.0 stars.
The 5.0 looks better but rests on three votes. A single bought or constructed rating can shift the picture completely in that case. With 40 ratings, far more fabrications would need to succeed before the average changed noticeably.
Incentives and rewards
Someone who receives a voucher, a discount or a gift for a rating has an interest in the outcome. That does not automatically make the rating false. It does mean the rating tells you less than an uninfluenced opinion would. Pay particular attention to prompts such as “Rate us and get a discount” and to texts that read like advertising.
Frequently asked questions
Can I report a fake review?
Yes, most review platforms and marketplaces offer a reporting function. Give a short reason, for example identical wording or no link to an order. If you have ordered the product yourself, you can also contact the provider directly and ask it to check the rating.
Can I have a negative review deleted?
That depends on the content. A true, even harsh, opinion is protected by freedom of expression. Untrue factual claims or insults can be challenged. A claim for deletion exists only if the content is concretely false or unlawful. In case of doubt, legal advice can help.
Are seals for verified reviews reliable?
A seal is only as reliable as the check behind it. Find out who awards the seal, which criteria apply and whether the reviews are collected in a traceable way. A seal without a visible procedure says little about whether individual ratings are genuine.
What should you do if you fell for a fake?
Keep the order confirmation, the invoice and screenshots of the review. A defective item falls under the rules on defects, regardless of which stars were shown. The article on returning defective goods from online orders (in German) explains how to proceed.
Why are reviews especially risky with fake shops?
Fraudulent shops often rely on fake reviews to build trust, so the reviews are part of the scheme. Always check reviews together with the imprint, the payment options and the contact details. More on this in the article on fake online shops (in German).
What you can do now
- Check the next review page with the steps in this guide before you order.
- Read the provider’s statements on the authenticity of its reviews, if it publishes any.
- Report suspicious posts instead of silently ignoring them.
- Keep the order confirmation and the invoice for every purchase, so you can act if something goes wrong.
Related articles
- Consumer rights in everyday life: protection against fraud and unfair contracts (in German)
- Fake online shops: how to recognise online fraud (in German)
- Fake tickets for concerts and festivals (in German)
- Prize game scams: why costs are often hidden (in German)
- Defects in online orders: how to complain correctly (in German)
Sources:
- Section 5b UWG, consumer reviews (Gesetze im Internet, Federal Ministry of Justice), wording retrieved on 2 November 2026
- Directive (EU) 2019/2161 (Omnibus Directive), official text
Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.