Short answer: According to a ruling by the Landgericht Itzehoe of 9 September 2010 (case no. 2 O 203/10), a prize game may not be advertised as free while costs arise. The case concerned a free-looking draw with a hidden subscription of 8 euro a month. The consumer advice centre reports that the judgment is final. Last updated: November 2026.
Prize games appear on the street, in social networks, at trade fairs and in online forms. Most are harmless or serve advertising. The problem starts when participation is not free or when you agree to a contract without noticing. Students who want to win a voucher or a phone are particularly exposed to this kind of cost trap.
The most important points
- According to the Itzehoe ruling, a draw advertised as free or without cost may not contain hidden charges.
- Hidden subscriptions often appear on the back of a participation form or in small print.
- The Landgericht Itzehoe decided such a case on 9 September 2010 (case no. 2 O 203/10).
- A notice about an additional subscription must be clearly visible, otherwise it loses its function as a warning.
- If you receive a payment demand, check the contract before you pay.
How does a prize game trap work?
The pattern is usually simple. A stand, a flyer or an online form promises an attractive prize. Taking part seems free, and the form is quick to fill in. On the back or in the small print, however, it says that you also take out a subscription that costs money every month. Anyone who does not read the details only notices the contract when the first invoice arrives.
The pattern is risky because the prize is in the foreground and the costs stay in the background. Especially problematic is the combination of an address, a signature and a subscription that is not explicitly explained. So pay attention to what you sign and which fields you complete.
What did the Itzehoe ruling decide?
The consumer advice centre of North Rhine-Westphalia (Verbraucherzentrale NRW) took action against an organiser that let passers-by take part in an allegedly free draw for a car. On the back of the participation card, however, the small print contained a subscription. It was to cost eight euro a month over two years, a total of 192 euro. Weeks later, participants received a payment demand.
In its judgment of 9 September 2010 (case no. 2 O 203/10), the Landgericht Itzehoe confirmed that it is impermissible to offer goods or services as free, gratis or at no cost when costs still arise. According to the consumer advice centre, the judgment is final. The centre also stresses that a notice about an additional subscription is required in prize games. The case therefore shows how important a clear and visible notice is.
The case is more than 15 years old, but the basic problem is the same. The tricks have changed, while the principles stay the same: hidden costs, unclear contracts and pressure after participation.
How do you spot hidden costs?
Before you enter your details, do a short check. Read the whole form, including the back and the footer. Look for terms such as subscription, trial month, magazine, membership or monthly fee. If you do not understand what you are confirming, leave the form alone.
Online prize games are not automatically trustworthy either. Check who the organiser is and whether there is an imprint with an address. Games that immediately ask for money, bank details or a credit card number are especially suspicious, because genuine prizes do not usually require an advance payment.
| Warning sign | What you should do |
|---|---|
| Prize advertised as free, but payment requested | stop the entry and check the details |
| Subscription mentioned only on the back | do not sign the form |
| Advance payment for a prize | do not make any payment |
| No imprint or an unclear organiser | skip the game |
What should you do if you have already agreed?
If you have already entered and receive an invoice, check the contract first. The form shows whether a subscription was agreed and what the term is. Keep the form, the payment demand and all correspondence. Then you can check whether you can cancel or withdraw.
Write to the provider promptly, in a form you can prove, to say that you do not accept the demand and to ask for clarification. If you are unsure, the consumer advice centre can help. Do not let yourself be pressured, and do not pay hastily if the contract is unclear. Our guide on debt collection letters (in German) explains how to handle collection demands.
- Read the form and look for subscription or cost notices.
- Keep all documents and note the date of your entry.
- Respond in writing to payment demands and ask for clarification.
- Get advice from the consumer advice centre if you are uncertain.
Why are the costs so often in the small print?
The placement is not a coincidence. A notice about a subscription often looks like a footnote on the entry form, because attention stays on the prize. Anyone who fills in the form quickly overlooks lines at the edge, on the back or in small type. Providers who want to sell a subscription without advertising it openly rely on exactly that.
For you, this is a signal to focus on the contract rather than the prize. Before any signature, ask yourself what you are agreeing to, how long the arrangement runs and which costs arise each month. If you cannot answer these questions, the form is not for you.
Prize games at trade fairs, events or shopping centres are not automatically dubious either. Transparency is what matters. A clear price, an understandable term and a clearly visible notice point to a fair offer.
Watch out for prize promises by phone
Prize promises made by phone are especially risky, because you have no time to read the details. Unsolicited advertising calls to consumers count as an unreasonable nuisance under § 7 para. 2 no. 1 UWG (Unfair Competition Act) unless the consumer has given prior express consent. You do not have to engage in a call in which a prize is promised to you.
In such cases, hang up and note the date, the time and the phone number if you can see it. If a confirmation then arrives by post or e-mail, check it as carefully as you would a form. No genuine prize requires you to make a decision on the phone straight away.
Frequently asked questions
Is a prize game with a subscription always unlawful?
No. What matters is whether the costs are clearly and visibly stated and whether the offer is advertised as free. A prize game that openly informs you about a subscription is different from a draw that hides the costs.
Do I have to pay a bill if I did not read the small print?
This cannot be answered in general terms. Whether a contract was validly concluded depends on the specific course of events and on the notice given. Have the matter checked by a consumer advice service before you pay.
How do I recognise a genuine prize game?
Genuine organisers state a clear name, an address and the terms of participation. Costs are stated transparently. Prizes are awarded without an advance payment.
What can I do about unwanted phone calls?
Unsolicited telephone advertising counts as an unreasonable nuisance unless express consent exists. Document the call and contact the consumer advice centre.
Who helps me with a payment demand?
The consumer advice centres offer first consultations. For legal questions about a specific contract, legal advice is worthwhile.
Related reading
- Consumer rights in everyday life: protection against fraud and unfair contracts (in German)
- Cancel an online subscription: what the cancellation button requires (in German)
- Debt collection letter received: what to check before you pay (in German)
- Fake concert and festival tickets: how to recognise fraud (in German)
- Fraud on sales platforms: warning signs when buying and selling (in German)
Sources: Notice about an additional subscription in prize games required (judgment of the Landgericht Itzehoe, case no. 2 O 203/10, Verbraucherzentrale, German), Section 7 UWG (unreasonable nuisances), Gesetze im Internet, retrieved on 2 November 2026
Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.