Smoking in a rented flat is a perennial topic in shared flats and dorms, and the legal position is less clear-cut than many assume. The German Civil Code (BGB) contains no express statutory smoking ban for your own rented flat. What counts are the lease, the house rules and the duty of consideration. In 2015 the Federal Court of Justice (Bundesgerichtshof, BGH) ruled on cigarette smell in a stairwell and set out what matters. For more on your rights see Can the landlord do that? (in German).
Kurz beantwortet: The BGH decision of 18 February 2015 (VIII ZR 186/14) does not use smoking as such as the yardstick. What matters is the smell nuisance: it can disturb house peace and breach the duty of consideration if you could avoid it by reasonable measures such as airing. It depends on the intensity in the individual case (last updated: November 2026).
Key points
- On 18 February 2015 (VIII ZR 186/14) the BGH ruled on termination over cigarette smell in a stairwell, not on smoking inside the flat as such.
- Smell nuisance can disturb house peace and breach the duty of consideration.
- That applies if the tenant could avoid it by simple, reasonable measures such as airing the flat.
- The intensity in the individual case matters, an unbearable and health-endangering degree points to a breach.
- Leases and house rules can regulate smoking, their validity depends on the wording.
What did the BGH decide about smoking in 2015?
The case concerned a 75-year-old tenant who had lived in the flat for 40 years and smoked about 15 cigarettes a day. The landlord terminated without notice, alternatively with notice, because cigarette smell reached the stairwell. She accused him of not airing enough and not emptying his ashtrays. The lower courts upheld the eviction claim. The BGH set aside the appeal judgment and sent the case back because the findings of fact were incomplete (account in German: Berliner Mieterverein on VIII ZR 186/14).
The senate held that smell nuisance from cigarette smoke can be a disturbance of house peace and a breach of the duty of consideration if the tenant could avoid it by simple, reasonable measures such as airing. The intensity decides in each case. The BGH did not decide whether the conditions for termination without notice (section 569(2) BGB) or ordinary termination (section 573(2) no. 1 BGB) were met.
When can smoking lead to termination?
Under the decision, the mere fact that you smoke is not enough. What counts are concrete, provable circumstances such as the intensity of the nuisance and whether it can be avoided. Termination requires a culpable, not insignificant breach of duty (section 573(2) no. 1 BGB) or a lasting disturbance of house peace (section 569(2) BGB). The courts must establish this in each case.
| Question | Yardstick under the BGH decision (as of November 2026) |
|---|---|
| Do you smoke in the flat? | The ruling does not test smoking as such, but its effect on others |
| Does smell reach the stairwell? | Can affect house peace and consideration if reasonable measures are omitted |
| Can you avoid the smell? | Simple measures such as airing are reasonable |
| How strong is the nuisance? | Intensity in the individual case, unbearable and health-endangering points to a breach |
What may the lease or house rules regulate?
Leases and house rules can regulate smoking expressly, for example in the stairwell or on shared areas. Whether a clause on smoking inside the flat is valid depends on its wording and on review as standard terms (cf. section 307 BGB). The decision discussed here gives no general rule on that, so have the specific contract text checked. In student dorms the operator’s house rules and fire-safety requirements often apply, which you should read before moving in.
Who is liable for smell and discolouration at move-out?
Changes to the property caused by contractual use are not the tenant’s responsibility under section 538 BGB. Whether nicotine deposits belong to that is judged case by case. For smell and discolouration the landlord will often want to use the deposit. See our guides on getting your deposit back and cosmetic repairs in the lease (both in German). Photos and a handover record at move-in are the most important evidence.
Smoking in a shared flat: what applies towards housemates?
In a shared flat the housemates matter as well as the landlord. The main tenant can set rules for the flat as far as the contract supports them, see main tenant or subtenant in a shared flat (in German). A written house agreement on smoking in the kitchen, bathroom and rooms avoids later dispute. Airing together and smoking on the balcony or outside are practical solutions that also make a landlord’s complaint less likely.
What should you do if the landlord warns you?
Read the warning carefully and check which nuisance is concretely complained of, who is affected and since when. In the 2015 case the BGH stressed that the courts must establish the facts carefully. For you that means collecting your own evidence, such as signs of regular airing or that the smell may come from other sources.
Reply in writing and factually, without disputing or admitting the allegations across the board. Advice from a tenants’ association or a lawyer clarifies whether the warning is justified. Do not wait until a termination arrives, because then deadlines start running that you must keep in view.
Frequently asked questions
Can my landlord ban smoking in my flat?
The BGH decision discussed here does not create a general ban for rented flats. Whether a contract clause works depends on its wording. When in doubt, have it checked by a tenants’ advice service.
Can I be given notice over cigarette smell?
It is possible if the smell nuisance breaches house peace and the duty of consideration and you could avoid it by reasonable measures. In the 2015 case the BGH did not decide conclusively but sent the case back.
Do I have to renovate at move-out because of smoking?
That depends on the contract, the condition at move-in and the damage. Check the cosmetic repairs clause and record the condition with photos.
May I smoke on the balcony?
The ruling does not deal with that. Whether the lease or house rules contain provisions and how neighbours are affected is decided case by case.
How to proceed
- Read the lease and house rules for rules on smoking.
- Air the flat regularly and avoid smell drifting into the stairwell or other flats.
- Address neighbours’ complaints early and put agreements in writing.
- Document the condition of the flat at move-in with photos and a record.
- If you receive a warning or notice, have the case checked by a tenants’ advice service or a lawyer.
Related guides
- Living while studying: rent, shared flats, dorms and housing benefit
- Can the landlord do that? Common questions
- Cosmetic repairs in the lease
- Handover record when taking over a flat
- Student Dorm or Shared Flat: Which Suits You Better?
Sources: BGH, judgment of 18 February 2015, VIII ZR 186/14 (account by Berliner Mieterverein), 2015. Statutes: section 569 BGB, section 573 BGB and section 538 BGB.
Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.