More info

Cosmetic Repairs in a Rental Contract: What Students Should Know

When a renovation clause in a German rental contract is invalid and who pays if you took over an unrenovated room. Case law of the BGH explained.
Zwei Studentinnen auf dem Campus im Herbst

Contents

Cosmetic repairs (Schönheitsreparaturen) in a rental contract are a frequent point of dispute when students move out: do I have to repaint, and who pays if I received an unrenovated room? Under the law the landlord must maintain the flat, and shifting that duty to you is only possible through a valid contract clause. How the room looked at handover often decides whether the clause is valid, see also our guide on the handover record (in German).

Kurz beantwortet: By law the landlord must keep the rented property in good condition (section 535(1) sentence 2 of the Civil Code, BGB). A clause making you do cosmetic repairs is invalid under BGH case law if you took over an unrenovated flat without reasonable compensation (BGH, 18 March 2015, VIII ZR 185/14, confirmed 8 July 2020, VIII ZR 163/18; last updated: November 2026).

Key points

  • Without a valid clause the landlord bears maintenance, under section 535(1) sentence 2 BGB.
  • If the flat was handed over unrenovated, the renovation clause is invalid without reasonable compensation (BGH, VIII ZR 185/14).
  • The statutory rule replaces an invalid clause (section 306(2) BGB).
  • If the condition deteriorates significantly, there can be a defect, with an advance payment under section 536a(2) no. 1 BGB.
  • As a rule the tenant must contribute half of the costs under good faith (BGH, VIII ZR 163/18).

What are cosmetic repairs?

The term covers usual renovation work caused by living in the flat, such as repainting walls. The law assigns maintenance to the landlord. Many standard-form leases transfer this duty to the tenant by a clause. Whether such a clause works is decided by the BGH’s case law on standard terms.

When is the cosmetic repairs clause invalid?

In its judgment of 18 March 2015 (VIII ZR 185/14) the BGH decided that a renovation clause is invalid if the tenant received an unrenovated flat without reasonable compensation. In its judgment of 8 July 2020 (VIII ZR 163/18) the senate, referring to the 2015 decision, confirmed that such clauses are invalid and set out the legal consequences in more detail: the statutory duty of the landlord to maintain the flat applies, if the decoration deteriorates materially the tenant can demand renovation and must as a rule bear half of the costs unless special circumstances apply (BGH press release of 8 July 2020, in German).

Condition at move-inEffect of the clause (as of November 2026)
Flat handed over renovated, valid clauseThe duty can rest with the tenant, validity depends on the wording
Flat handed over unrenovated, no reasonable compensationClause invalid, statutory rule applies (section 306(2) BGB)
Flat handed over unrenovated, reasonable compensationClause can be valid if you are placed as if you had received a renovated flat
No clause in the contractMaintenance lies with the landlord (section 535(1) sentence 2 BGB)

What applies if the clause is invalid?

Then the statutory rule replaces it under section 306(2) BGB, and the landlord bears maintenance. The unrenovated condition at handover can be the agreed standard. If it deteriorates significantly, there is a defect, and you can claim an advance payment under section 536a(2) no. 1 BGB. Because renovation leaves you better off than the original condition, good faith (section 242 BGB) requires you to contribute to the costs, as a rule half. In 2020 the appeal judgment was set aside and sent back so that the necessity of the work and the cost share could be clarified.

Worked example: sharing renovation costs

Assumption: your shared-flat room was unrenovated, the clause is invalid, and after several years renovation is necessary because of significant deterioration. The necessary costs are 900 euros.

ItemAmount
Necessary renovation costs900 euros
Your share (as a rule half, BGH VIII ZR 163/18)450 euros
Landlord’s share450 euros

The split is the rule, not a fixed formula. What matters remains which costs are necessary. The figures are an example, not a price for painting work.

What role does the handover record play at move-in?

Because the condition at handover counts for the validity of the clause, documentation at move-in is decisive. Note in the record whether walls were freshly painted and where wear is visible. Add dated photos and have the landlord or main tenant countersign. Without a record it is harder to prove the condition in a dispute.

A joint record at move-out is also worthwhile. It shows which work the landlord actually demands and prevents later claims against your deposit. See our guide to the rent deposit for students (in German).

What applies in a shared flat or dorm?

In a shared flat the rules govern the relationship between you and your contract partner, the landlord or the main tenant, see main tenant or subtenant in a shared flat (in German). Check who bears the renovation duty and how the room looked when you moved in. Photos at move-in and a handover record are the most important evidence. In student dorms the contracts sometimes refer to the operator’s own rules, which you should read in each case.

What should you watch for when the landlord makes demands?

If the landlord demands that you repaint or pay renovation costs at move-out, first check the clause and the move-in condition. Do not pay hastily, but ask for a comprehensible cost breakdown. Whether the costs are necessary is, after the 2020 judgment, a point the courts must clarify. Advice from a tenants’ association or a lawyer helps classify your actual contract text.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to repaint when I move out?

That depends on the clause in the contract and the condition at move-in. If the clause is invalid, the landlord bears maintenance under section 535(1) sentence 2 BGB. When in doubt, check the wording with a tenants’ advice service. Even if the clause is valid, you owe only the usual work, not renovation beyond the condition at move-in.

What does “unrenovated” at move-in mean?

It means the flat already showed signs of use. The BGH looks at the condition at handover. Record it in the handover record with photos.

Can the landlord keep my deposit?

If the landlord claims renovation costs on the basis of an invalid clause, there is no basis for it. On deposits and moving out see getting your rent deposit back (in German).

Does this apply to older contracts?

The judgments concern the validity of standard-form clauses. Whether they apply to an older contract depends on the individual case. Only a check of the wording can classify your specific contract.

How to proceed

  1. Read the cosmetic repairs clause in the lease.
  2. Check whether the flat was renovated at move-in, and secure evidence such as photos and the handover record.
  3. Clarify whether you received compensation for taking over an unrenovated flat.
  4. Respond to the landlord’s demands in writing and ask for the basis of the calculation.
  5. Have unclear cases checked by a tenants’ advice service or a lawyer.

Related guides

Sources: Federal Court of Justice, press release on the judgments of 8 July 2020, VIII ZR 163/18 and VIII ZR 270/18 (retrieved 2 November 2026, in German). section 535 BGB. Statutes: section 306 BGB and section 536a BGB.

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Gatekeeper model over 30: what it means for costs and fund choice

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Requesting a contribution certificate from your health insurer

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Fund merger or closure: what happens to contribution and membership