Reimbursement cut or refused: what to do with a PKV bill

If a private insurer cuts or refuses a bill, the stated reason and the policy terms come first. Steps, deadlines and the PKV Ombudsman are explained in this guide.
Studentin liest am Küchentisch ein Schreiben ihrer Krankenkasse

Contents

If your private health insurer cuts or refuses a bill, you can first check the reason given, then ask for a written explanation and, if needed, object in writing. Academycon, an insurance broker in Göttingen focused on students, trainee civil servants and graduates, explains which steps make sense, which deadlines apply and who can help when a dispute arises.

Author: Academycon editorial team. Published: November 2, 2026. Last reviewed: November 2, 2026.

Short answer: A reimbursement that has been cut or refused should first be checked against the stated reason and the policy terms. You can then ask the insurer in writing for a more precise explanation and lodge an objection. Claims under insurance contracts generally become time-barred after three years. In a dispute, the PKV Ombudsman handles complaints from policyholders. Last updated: November 2026.

The key points in brief

  • A cut or refusal is not a final decision but the start of a review.
  • The written reason from the insurer shows which rule it applies and forms the basis of your reply.
  • Send objections in writing and note the deadlines stated in the letter.
  • Claims under insurance contracts generally become time-barred after three years, though individual cases need checking.
  • In a dispute, you can involve the PKV Ombudsman before you go to court.

Why does a private insurer cut or refuse a bill?

The most frequent reasons are a deviation from the agreed fee multiplier, a missing justification for a higher factor, a question about medical necessity or an exclusion in the tariff. Deductibles and waiting periods can also mean that an amount is not reimbursed in full or at all. A refusal therefore often concerns not the treatment itself but how the bill is to be assessed under the tariff.

For that reason, the first step is always to read the letter. Look at which item is affected, which amount was reduced and which provision the insurer cites. A general phrase such as “not reimbursable” is not enough to review a decision.

What can you do about a reduced reimbursement?

A reduction can be checked in three steps. First, compare the item on the bill with the statement of reimbursement. Then read the policy terms for this service. Finally, ask the insurer in writing on what basis the reduction was made. This request is not an objection but a request for clarification, which often makes the decision easier to assess.

StepWhat you doWhat you need
Read the reasonIdentify the affected item and provisionStatement of reimbursement and bill
Check the tariffRead the reimbursement rule and exclusionsPolicy terms
AskRequest the reason in writingLetter to the insurer
ObjectSet out your arguments in writingEvidence and the doctor’s justification
Status and sourceLast updated: November 2026. Limitation under the rules of the German Insurance Contract Act (VVG), policy terms of the insurerInsurer and statute

Check also whether the cut affects only part of the bill or the whole amount. Often the dispute concerns a single position, such as material costs, a laboratory item or an increased factor, while the rest is paid without question. Separating these helps you limit the objection to the position actually in dispute.

How do I lodge an objection?

An objection should be in writing and clearly traceable. State your policy number, the date of the bill, the affected item and the amount. Explain briefly why you consider the reduction wrong, and enclose the doctor’s justification if the doctor has explained the factor. Keep a copy and proof of sending. A personal explanation on the phone does not replace a written objection.

If you feel unsure, collect your arguments first and formulate them calmly. A short letter with clear evidence is often more effective than a long text without reference to the tariff.

How much time do I have?

Claims under insurance contracts generally become time-barred after three years. The exact start of the period depends on the individual case, so do not wait until the last moment. Many insurers also state in their letter a separate deadline for a query or an objection. That deadline takes priority over general considerations, because it sets the path for the next step.

Note the date of the letter and the day it arrived. Open a separate file for each disputed bill, with letters and receipts in chronological order, so that you keep track when several matters run in parallel.

Typical mistakes when objecting

The most common mistake is to lodge an objection only by phone or with a general sentence. Without specific details on the bill, item and amount, the insurer can hardly review the letter, and processing is delayed. A second mistake is to overlook deadlines stated in the refusal letter, which can be shorter than the general limitation period. Someone who lets such a deadline pass may lose the chance to challenge the decision.

An objection should also not question the whole bill if only one item is disputed. A precise argument on one position is more credible than a blanket objection. Finally, document every payment so that it remains clear later what has already been reimbursed.

Who helps in a dispute with the insurer?

In a dispute you can involve the PKV Ombudsman, who receives and examines complaints from policyholders. Consumer protection centres also offer advice, and you should ask in advance about their fees. For larger amounts or legal questions, a lawyer who specialises in insurance law is the right contact. Advice does not replace a review of the specific case, and whether the route is worthwhile depends on the amount at stake.

Frequently asked questions

How do I lodge an objection?

You lodge an objection in writing and state your policy number, the bill date, the affected item and the amount. Explain briefly why you consider the reduction wrong and keep proof of sending.

Who helps in a dispute with the insurer?

The PKV Ombudsman receives and examines complaints from policyholders. Consumer protection centres offer advice, and a lawyer specialising in insurance law can help with larger amounts.

How long do I have?

Claims under insurance contracts generally become time-barred after three years. Deadlines stated in the insurer’s letter for queries or objections must be met, so check them immediately.

Do I have to enclose the doctor’s justification?

Not in every case, but it helps when the factor or the necessity of treatment is disputed. A short justification from the doctor strengthens your argument.

Next steps for you

  1. Read the reason and mark the affected item with its amount and the provision cited.
  2. Check the reimbursement rule and the exclusions in the policy terms.
  3. Request the reason in writing if necessary and file an objection within the stated deadline.
  4. If something remains unclear, a personal consultation is possible through Academycon.

Related guides

About Academycon

Academycon GmbH is an insurance broker based in Göttingen. The editorial team publishes guides on health insurance, student funding and protection for students, trainee civil servants and graduates.

Sources: German Insurance Contract Act, section 195 VVG (limitation), last updated November 2026. PKV Ombudsman, complaints procedure, last updated November 2026.

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Studentin liest am Küchentisch ein Schreiben ihrer Krankenkasse

Sports injury and surgery: when private insurance pays

Studentin liest am Küchentisch ein Schreiben ihrer Krankenkasse

Transplant and organ costs in private insurance: tariff cover

Studentin liest am Küchentisch ein Schreiben ihrer Krankenkasse

Cosmetic treatments in private insurance: what is not reimbursed