More info

Re-Employment Bar in German Academia: What It Means

Re-employment bar at German universities: what the follow-on ban in section 14 TzBfG means, how it fits the WissZeitVG and what the reform plans.
Doktorandin arbeitet im Büro an ihrer Dissertation

Contents

The “re-employment bar” (Wiederbeschäftigungssperre) is a term that comes up at German universities when a new contract is planned after a fixed-term one. It does not appear as a fixed statutory term in the Academic Fixed-Term Contracts Act (WissZeitVG); neither section 1 WissZeitVG nor the wording of section 14(2) sentence 2 TzBfG uses it (retrieved on 2 November 2026). What people usually mean is the follow-on ban (Anschlussverbot, also called prior-employment ban) in the Part-Time and Fixed-Term Employment Act (TzBfG). This guide explains what it is and how it interacts with the WissZeitVG.

Short answer: The follow-on ban is in section 14(2) sentence 2 TzBfG and applies to fixed terms without an objective reason: they are not allowed if a fixed-term or permanent employment relationship with the same employer already existed. The law names no fixed waiting period. In 2018 the Federal Constitutional Court allowed exceptions for prior employment that was very long ago, of a completely different kind, or very short (last updated: November 2026).

Key points

  • “Wiederbeschäftigungssperre” is not a statutory term. Legally the issue is the follow-on ban in section 14(2) sentence 2 TzBfG.
  • The ban concerns fixed terms without an objective reason. Under section 14(2) TzBfG these are possible for up to two years, with at most three extensions within that period.
  • There is no rigid waiting period. The former three-year reading by the Federal Labour Court no longer counts as a fixed limit since the Federal Constitutional Court decision of 6 June 2018.
  • Under section 1(2) WissZeitVG universities may also use fixed terms under the TzBfG. Contracts under section 2 WissZeitVG follow the maximum durations of that act.
  • A draft bill reforming the WissZeitVG contains an exception from the follow-on ban for student-support activities. It has not been adopted.

Is there a re-employment bar in the WissZeitVG?

Sections 2, 3 and 6 of the WissZeitVG regulate fixed-term employment of academic and artistic staff at state universities, except professors. Under section 1(1) sentence 2, these rules cannot be deviated from by agreement (section 1 WissZeitVG, in German). Section 1 WissZeitVG provides for no waiting period after the end of a contract.

What employees mean when they speak of a bar is almost always the follow-on ban in general fixed-term law. It concerns whether the same university may hire you again on a fixed term without an objective reason after an earlier employment relationship.

What does the follow-on ban in section 14(2) TzBfG regulate?

Under section 14(2) sentence 1 TzBfG, a fixed term without an objective reason is allowed for up to two years, with up to three extensions within that period (section 14 TzBfG, in German). Sentence 2 excludes this option if a fixed-term or permanent employment relationship with the same employer already existed.

Two things follow. First, every earlier employment relationship counts, not only fixed-term ones. Second, what matters is the contractual employer, not the workplace or the institute. If you previously worked as an assistant at the same university, you therefore have prior employment within the meaning of this rule.

How long ago must the prior employment have been so that it no longer counts?

For a long time the Federal Labour Court read the ban so that it did not apply if the prior employment was more than three years ago. Since the Federal Constitutional Court decision of 6 June 2018 (1 BvL 7/14, 1 BvR 1375/14) it no longer holds to that reading. In its judgment of 17 April 2019 (7 AZR 324/17) the court states that the three-year period is no longer a fixed threshold (BAG, 7 AZR 324/17, in German).

Instead the ban is “not unlimited”. It is unreasonable where there is no risk of chains of fixed terms and the ban is not needed to preserve permanent employment as the normal form of work. The Federal Constitutional Court named three examples.

CategoryMeaningOutcome in the BAG case 7 AZR 324/17
Very long agoThe prior employment lies exceptionally far backA little over 15 years was not enough without further circumstances
Completely differentThe earlier work differs fundamentally from the new workA different workplace is not enough, substantially different knowledge or skills are required
Very shortThe prior employment lasted only a very short timeJust under ten months was not considered very short

Anyone relying on such an exception must present the facts. In the decided case that was the employer. The categories leave room for judgment and are always assessed case by case.

How does the follow-on ban work for university contracts?

The university has two routes. It can use a fixed term under section 2 WissZeitVG, for example a qualification term of up to six years before and six years after the doctorate, or under section 2(2) for third-party funded positions. Or it uses the option in section 1(2) WissZeitVG to use a fixed term under the TzBfG, then with all TzBfG rules. For a fixed term without an objective reason, that includes the follow-on ban.

The maximum durations of the WissZeitVG are separate statutory limits. The act itself does not provide an additional waiting period after an earlier contract. How the two sets of rules relate in an individual case is a legal question. Works councils (Personalrat), trade unions or an employment law specialist can help. For an overview of the legal basis see What is the WissZeitVG? and, on chains of contracts, Chain fixed-term contracts in academia (both in German).

What does the WissZeitVG reform plan on the follow-on ban?

The draft act modernising fixed-term law in academia (Bundesrat printed paper 456/26 of 14 August 2026; the Bundestag reported the government bill as printed paper 21/8281 on 5 October 2026) provides for a new section 2(3a) WissZeitVG. It is meant to create an exception from the follow-on ban in section 14(2) sentence 2 TzBfG for activities supporting students’ studies (Bundesrat printed paper 456/26, in German).

As entry into force the draft names the first day of the sixth calendar month after promulgation, no date is set yet. The draft has not been adopted, and the legislative procedure was ongoing according to the Bundestag report of 5 October 2026 (procedural status since then not checked, see bundestag.de for current information; Bundestag, hib 771/2026, in German). This exception is particularly relevant for student assistants who want to keep working at the same university after their degree. More details are in WissZeitVG amendment: what the draft bill plans for assistants (in German).

A worked example on prior employment

Assumption: You work as a student assistant at a university from October 2023 to September 2024 and complete your master’s degree in 2026. The university wants to offer you a two-year contract without an objective reason.

  1. Check whether the university would again be your contractual employer. Then there is prior employment under section 14(2) sentence 2 TzBfG.
  2. Check whether one of the three exceptions could apply. The prior employment lasted twelve months and ended a few years ago, so it is neither very long ago nor very short. Whether the work is “completely different” depends on the tasks.
  3. Ask on which legal basis the university bases the new contract, for example a qualification aim under section 2 WissZeitVG. Then the maximum durations of that act matter.

Frequently asked questions

Does the re-employment bar only apply at universities?

The term is not a statutory term. The follow-on ban in section 14(2) sentence 2 TzBfG applies to fixed terms without an objective reason in all sectors, not only at universities. The WissZeitVG adds its own maximum durations.

Is everything allowed again after three years?

No. The three-year limit was a former interpretation by the Federal Labour Court. Since the Federal Constitutional Court decision of 6 June 2018 it is, according to judgment 7 AZR 324/17, no longer a fixed threshold. Exceptions apply only to prior employment that was very long ago, of a completely different kind or very short.

Does employment as an assistant count as prior employment?

According to the wording, any earlier fixed-term or permanent employment relationship with the same employer counts. Whether the WissZeitVG reform draft will bring an exception for student-support activities is still open, as it has not been adopted.

What happens if the fixed term is invalid?

In a dispute the labour court decides. Under the TzBfG the consequence of an invalid fixed term is normally an open-ended employment relationship. Which deadlines apply to a claim should be clarified with a trade union or specialist lawyer before the contract ends.

How to proceed now

  1. List all earlier contracts with the university: start, end, type of work and contractual employer.
  2. Ask before signing on which legal basis the fixed term rests, WissZeitVG or TzBfG.
  3. For WissZeitVG contracts, note the maximum durations of six years before and six years after the doctorate.
  4. If in doubt, seek advice from the works council, a trade union or an employment law specialist.

Related guides

Sources: Section 1 WissZeitVG, gesetze-im-internet.de, Section 14 TzBfG, gesetze-im-internet.de (last amended 20 July 2022), Federal Labour Court, judgment of 17 April 2019, 7 AZR 324/17, Bundesrat printed paper 456/26 (14 August 2026), Bundestag, hib 771/2026 (5 October 2026).

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Gatekeeper model over 30: what it means for costs and fund choice

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Requesting a contribution certificate from your health insurer

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Fund merger or closure: what happens to contribution and membership