More info

Prepaid or Contract for Your Phone: What Pays Off for Students

Prepaid or a fixed-term contract? The German Federal Network Agency sets a maximum initial term of 24 months and requires providers to offer 12-month contracts.
Zwei Studentinnen auf dem Campus im Herbst

Contents

If you need a new phone for your studies, you will soon face the question of whether a prepaid card or a fixed-term contract suits you better. The answer depends on how much you call, how much data you need and how long you want to be bound. This guide explains the differences based on information from the German Federal Network Agency (Bundesnetzagentur).

Short answer: The Federal Network Agency states that the initial minimum term of a contract between a consumer and a provider may not exceed 24 months. Providers must also offer a contract with a maximum term of twelve months. With prepaid, you need to top up after the activation period has ended. Last updated: November 2026. Source: Federal Network Agency (page marked as 2026).

The most important points at a glance

  • According to the Federal Network Agency, the initial minimum term may be at most 24 months.
  • Providers must also have a contract with a maximum term of twelve months in their range.
  • With prepaid, the card stays active only if you top up again after the activation period ends.
  • According to the Federal Network Agency, remaining credit stays in place even if you do not top up.
  • For suspension due to payment default, the law sets thresholds that you should know.

How does prepaid differ from a fixed-term contract?

Both models connect you to a network but differ in commitment and billing. With a prepaid card, you control usage through a credit balance. With a fixed-term contract, you agree to a set duration and pay regularly, usually monthly.

FeaturePrepaidFixed-term contract
CommitmentNo fixed contract term in the classic senseMinimum term, at most 24 months according to the Federal Network Agency
ActivationAfter the activation period ends, you must top up againThe contract runs for the agreed period
CreditRemains in place even without a top-up, according to the Federal Network AgencyBilling follows the contract terms
Termination with remaining creditYou can demand payout and set a deadlineRules follow the contract

The classification in the table rests on the Federal Network Agency statements on minimum term, activation and credit. The specific terms of an individual provider must be checked in its own contract.

Which terms are permitted for fixed-term contracts?

According to the Federal Network Agency, the initial minimum term of a contract between a consumer and a provider is at most 24 months (section 56 of the Telecommunications Act, TKG). Providers must also offer a contract with a maximum term of twelve months. A fixed-term contract therefore does not have to run for two years if you want a shorter commitment.

For students, this matters most when life plans are uncertain, for example if a semester abroad or a move is coming up. Still, the shorter term can look different in monthly costs than a long contract. Compare the total costs over the period you will actually use.

Worked example: what does prepaid cost over a year?

Assumption for the worked example: you top up 10 euros each month to keep the card active. Over twelve months this adds up to 120 euros of top-ups. Whether this amount fits your usage depends on the tariff and your habits. The provider publishes the current price of a tariff on its price page.

Then compare the total with the annual amount of a fixed-term contract that you can actually compare. Include device costs, one-off fees and possible activation charges, because they can change the result considerably.

What applies to suspension and payment default?

Under section 61 TKG, a provider may suspend service for payment default if the arrears, after deducting any advance payments, amount to at least 100 euros. Before that, it must threaten the suspension in writing at least two weeks in advance and point out the available legal remedies. If the default concerns only part of a bundled offer, only that component may be suspended.

With prepaid, whether the provider may deactivate the card depends on your contract. The Federal Network Agency refers to the consumer advice centres or a lawyer for this. For you, this means reading the terms on top-ups and deactivation before you decide.

When does prepaid suit you, and when a fixed-term contract?

Prepaid can suit you if you make few calls, need mobile data only occasionally and do not want a commitment. A fixed-term contract makes more sense if you regularly use a lot of data, want to finance a new device or prefer predictable monthly costs. Both models have their strengths, and the choice depends on your usage profile.

A common mistake is to compare only the monthly price. If you set a prepaid offer against a fixed-term contract, calculate the costs over a fixed period, for example twelve months. Also consider whether you need a device, because device costs with fixed-term contracts are often distributed differently than with a prepaid card that you use with your own phone.

Reachability during the semester is another point. If you depend on a phone number, for example for authorities, training employers or a part-time job, check in advance whether your credit covers the usage and whether activation happens in time. An expired activation is especially inconvenient when you urgently need the number.

If you are planning a switch, match the term to your life plans. A short term gives you room if your studies change, for example through a change of course or an internship abroad. A long term is worth it mainly if you are sure you will use the offer for the whole period.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to sign a contract with prepaid?

The Federal Network Agency describes prepaid cards as credit cards that are activated for a limited period. Which contractual duties arise follows from the provider’s terms, which you should read before buying.

Does my credit expire if I do not top up?

According to the Federal Network Agency, existing credit remains in place even if you do not top up. However, after the activation period ends, the card is only reactivated with a top-up. Check therefore how the provider handles activation.

What happens to remaining credit after termination?

If a contract is terminated with remaining credit, you can ask the provider to pay it out and set a deadline. The Federal Network Agency does not name concrete deadlines, so make the request in writing and document when it arrived.

Are there fixed notice periods for mobile contracts?

The Federal Network Agency page does not name concrete notice periods. The details of how to terminate are covered in our guide on cancelling a mobile contract, which you will find below.

What to do now

  1. Note how much you call, write and use the internet on the move each month, so that you can compare offers.
  2. With prepaid, check when the activation expires and how you need to top up.
  3. For fixed-term contracts, compare the total cost over the period you actually use, including device costs.
  4. Read the terms on suspension, remaining credit and termination before you sign.

Related reading

Sources: Federal Network Agency, questions and answers on contracts (as stated on the page, 2026)

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Gatekeeper model over 30: what it means for costs and fund choice

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Requesting a contribution certificate from your health insurer

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Fund merger or closure: what happens to contribution and membership