More info

Guarantee or Statutory Warranty in Germany: Who Is Liable for Defects

Guarantee and statutory warranty are constantly confused in Germany. Here you learn who is liable for a defect, how long statutory warranty runs and what a voluntary guarantee adds on top.
Zwei Studentinnen auf dem Campus im Herbst

Contents

Short answer: Statutory warranty (Gewährleistung) is the seller’s legal liability for material defects that exist at the time of purchase. For movable goods, § 438 para. 1 no. 3 BGB (German Civil Code) generally sets a limitation period of two years from delivery. A guarantee is a voluntary promise that can grant additional rights. Last updated: November 2026.

In everyday life, the words guarantee and statutory warranty are often used as if they meant the same thing. They do not. They have different obligors, different deadlines and different rules on proof. Knowing the difference helps you find out quickly whom to contact about a faulty laptop, a washing machine or a bicycle.

The most important points

  • Statutory warranty is required by law and applies primarily against the seller.
  • For movable goods, the limitation period for material defects is generally two years from delivery under § 438 BGB.
  • Under § 477 para. 1 BGB, a defect that appears within one year of the transfer of risk is presumed to have existed already at purchase.
  • A guarantee is a voluntary promise by the manufacturer or seller and applies in addition to your statutory rights.
  • Which guarantee applies and for how long is set out in the guarantee certificate or the terms.

What does statutory warranty mean in German sales law?

Statutory warranty describes the seller’s legal liability that the goods have the agreed quality and are free from defects when handed over. It does not depend on the manufacturer and applies to every purchase, including purchases where no guarantee was offered. The seller is your direct contact, even if the manufacturer is a different company.

Typical statutory rights include subsequent performance (repair or replacement), withdrawal from the contract, a reduction of the price and, under certain conditions, damages. Which right you can assert first depends on the case. As a rule, you must first give the seller the opportunity to remedy the defect. Our guide to complaints about online orders (in German) explains how to approach this properly.

How long does statutory warranty last?

For movable goods, the limitation period for claims arising from material defects is generally two years under § 438 para. 1 no. 3 BGB. Under § 438 para. 2 BGB, it starts with delivery of the goods. The receipt date therefore matters more than the date of the order. If delivery was delayed, check the delivery slip.

Example for illustration: Assumption: you receive a smartphone on 10 November 2026 that you ordered on 2 November 2026. The statutory limitation period for material defects then generally ends on 10 November 2028. Note the date from which the period runs so that you can act in time.

TermWho is liableDurationBasis
Statutory warrantythe sellergenerally two years from delivery§ 438 BGB
Presumption of a defect at purchasethe sellerone year from transfer of risk§ 477 BGB
Guaranteemanufacturer or seller, depending on the promiseas stated in the guarantee termsvoluntary promise

What does the one year presumption mean?

If a condition that deviates from the contractual requirements appears within one year of the transfer of risk, § 477 para. 1 BGB presumes that the goods were already defective at the transfer of risk. The presumption does not apply if it is incompatible with the nature of the goods or of the defect. For you, this means that during the first twelve months you do not have to prove that the fault already existed at purchase.

After this year, the burden of proof generally shifts. You may then have to show that the defect already existed when the goods were handed over. It is therefore sensible to document any irregularities early. Photos, error messages and a short note with the date help you here.

What does a guarantee add?

A guarantee is a voluntary promise given by the manufacturer or seller. It can have a longer term, include additional services or simplify the process, for example through a repair at no charge. What matters is the content of the guarantee declaration. It sets out what is promised, how long the guarantee lasts and what you must do to claim it.

A guarantee does not replace statutory warranty. You can usually use both routes. Still, check whether the guarantee depends on conditions, such as registration or presenting the proof of purchase. A guarantee promise that is not recorded in writing is harder to prove in a dispute.

How do you check which claim applies?

Before you contact anyone, take stock. First clarify whether you are dealing with a defect that already existed at purchase or with damage caused by incorrect use. Statutory warranty covers defects that were present on handover or appear within the statutory presumption period. Wear from normal use generally does not fall under it, although the line depends on the individual case.

Then look at the guarantee documents. If they state that the manufacturer repairs or replaces the product within a specific period, you can use that route in addition. Guarantees often cover only certain damage, such as material or manufacturing faults, and expressly exclude other causes. Knowing both routes saves time.

A typical mistake is to write to the manufacturer when the retailer is liable. That can cost weeks. Conversely, if a guarantee exists, do not address only the seller, because the manufacturer may sometimes offer a faster repair.

  • Proof of purchase and delivery date
  • Guarantee certificate and its terms, including exclusions
  • Description of the defect with photos or measurements
  • A decision on whether to pursue statutory warranty or the guarantee first

This list does not replace an individual check. It helps you arrange the documents so that the seller, the manufacturer or a consumer advice service can react quickly.

Frequently asked questions

Do I have to contact the manufacturer first if something is broken?

No. Your statutory claim is directed against the seller. The manufacturer is your contact only if it has given a guarantee. A guarantee can help you, but it does not replace the claim against the seller.

How long is statutory warranty for a used item?

The basic rule also applies to used goods, but the limitation period can be assessed differently in individual cases. For a private purchase, ask for the terms to be confirmed in writing and check the details in the contract.

Does statutory warranty also cover minor defects?

Statutory warranty covers material defects. Whether a defect exists and how serious it is depends on the individual case. Document even minor defects if they affect the product.

What is the difference between a guarantee and an exchange?

An exchange is often a voluntary gesture by the retailer and follows its own rules. Statutory warranty is a legal claim to subsequent performance. Check which route applies before you send the goods back.

When does a consumer advice service help?

If the seller disputes your claim or the deadline is getting close, a consumer advice centre can give a first assessment.

So what should you do now?

  1. Check the proof of purchase, the delivery date and the guarantee certificate, if you have one.
  2. Document the defect with photos and dates.
  3. Ask the seller in writing for subsequent performance and set a reasonable deadline.
  4. Contact the manufacturer in parallel if the guarantee provides for it.

Related reading

Sources: § 438 BGB: limitation of claims for defects (gesetze-im-internet.de, German), § 477 BGB: burden of proof in consumer sales (lxgesetze.de, German)

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Gatekeeper model over 30: what it means for costs and fund choice

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Requesting a contribution certificate from your health insurer

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Fund merger or closure: what happens to contribution and membership