More info

Partial or Comprehensive Car Cover for New Drivers

Partial or comprehensive car cover as a new driver in Germany? What both variants cover, which levers you control and how to decide by the value of your car.
Studentin mit Fahrradhelm vor einem Universitätsgebäude

Contents

Partial or comprehensive cover for new drivers: the question arises as soon as you register your own car and want to insure damage to it beyond the legally required liability cover. The two variants differ mainly for accidents you cause yourself and for vandalism. This guide shows the differences, the levers you control and the criteria for your decision. It deliberately gives no tariff recommendation.

In short: Partial cover (Teilkasko) typically covers theft, natural hazards, fire, collisions with animals and glass breakage. Comprehensive cover (Vollkasko) adds damage from accidents and vandalism, including accidents you cause yourself. Both apply only within the policy terms and any agreed excess. Which one fits depends mainly on the value of the car and your savings. Last updated: November 2026.

Key points

  • Motor liability insurance pays for other people’s damage. Partial and comprehensive cover protect your own vehicle and are optional building blocks.
  • The core difference: according to a direct insurer’s product information sheet, comprehensive cover also covers accident damage and vandalism, partial cover does not.
  • You pay the excess yourself when a claim occurs. The higher it is, the larger your own share.
  • The type class of your model and your no-claims class as a new driver affect the premium. Each insurer states concrete amounts in its tariff.
  • Intent is not insured in either variant. Exclusions and duties are set out in the policy terms.

What is the difference between partial and comprehensive cover?

The GDV model terms (AKB 2015, section A.2 on own-damage cover) show the usual split. Partial cover (Teilkasko) essentially covers fire and explosion, theft, natural hazards such as storm, hail and flooding, collision with wild game and glass breakage. Damage from accidents, including accidents you cause yourself, is not covered under partial cover. Comprehensive cover (Vollkasko) includes partial cover and, in addition, accident damage and malicious destruction by third parties (vandalism). Wear and tear and racing are not insured. Individual tariffs extend the scope, for example to animal bites. What counts is the wording of your terms.

Type of damagePartial coverComprehensive cover
Theft, fire, storm, hail, floodingInsuredInsured
Collision with animals, animal bitesInsured, details per policy termsInsured, details per policy terms
Glass breakageInsuredInsured
Self-caused accident damaging your own carNot insuredInsured
VandalismNot insuredInsured
Racing and wear and tearNot insuredNot insured
IntentNot insuredNot insured

The exact scope differs by tariff. The policy terms always prevail, and you should read them before signing. The same product information sheet notes, for example, that in that tariff only 70 percent of the costs are reimbursed if the repair is not done in the insurer’s workshop network, unless free choice of workshop has been agreed. Details like this matter when a claim occurs.

What levers do you have as a new driver?

As a new driver you usually start without a no-claims discount. Three levers remain.

  • Excess: This is the amount you pay yourself when a claim occurs. A higher excess shifts risk to you. How much it changes the premium is set by each insurer in its tariff.
  • Type class: The rating of your vehicle model affects the premium. A new type class can be a reason for premium changes, as ADAC also writes. How the rating works is explained in the guide to type classes 2027.
  • Choice of vehicle: Value, age and model determine how much comprehensive protection makes sense at all. An older car with a low current value calls for a different assessment than a new one.

How liability cover, the mandatory building block, is set up for new drivers is described in car liability insurance for new drivers. Collision cover builds on it. Discounts also include the proof for student discounts and the transfer of a no-claims class.

When does partial cover fit, and when does comprehensive cover?

There is no universal answer. The comparison below helps you weigh it up.

CriterionPoints towards partial coverPoints towards comprehensive cover
Value of the carLow current value, a write-off would be bearableHigh current value, your own share would be hard to carry
SavingsYou could pay for a repair after your own accidentA self-caused accident would break your budget
Financing or leasingNo requirements in the contractThe contract requires collision cover, check your contract documents
Parking and surroundingsGarage, low vandalism riskStreet parking in dense housing
Driving experienceYou have driven safely for years even if the insurance is newYou are still gaining experience and expect your own mistakes

An example for orientation. Assumption: after an accident you caused, your car has repair damage of 3,200 euros, and the agreed excess is 500 euros. With comprehensive cover the insurer pays 2,700 euros within the terms and you bear 500 euros. With partial cover you bear the full 3,200 euros yourself, because accident damage is not insured there. How large your savings would need to be to absorb this case is the real decision question.

What happens to the premium after a collision claim?

The downgrade of the no-claims class is a common reason for rising premiums, so your premium can rise after a settlement. How the downgrade works in detail depends on the tariff. Before you report any damage, check how your contract classifies collision claims. If the premium changes later without your involvement, the guide car insurance got more expensive sets out the rules on special termination.

What should you look for in the policy terms?

Two tariffs with the same label can differ considerably in the small print. Before signing, check four points: the range of insured perils, the excess for partial and comprehensive cover, any workshop requirements and the exclusions, for example for intent. Also note how the insurer classifies claims and when it adjusts premiums. This information is in the policy terms and in the insurance product information document. If you compare it, you decide on the basis of cover and not only the monthly premium.

Frequently asked questions

Is comprehensive cover mandatory for new drivers?

Motor liability insurance is required by law. Partial and comprehensive cover are optional building blocks. Whether a leasing or financing contract requires collision cover is stated in the contract documents.

Does partial cover include collisions with wild animals?

The product information sheet lists collision with animals as part of partial cover. Which animals exactly are covered and which evidence the insurer requires is set out in the terms of your tariff.

Does collision cover pay for gross negligence?

Intent is not insured. For gross negligence, alcohol or drugs the product information sheet gives no detailed rule. The consequences are set out in the policy terms and in the Insurance Contract Act. Read those clauses before you decide.

Can I change the variant later?

Whether and when you can switch from partial to comprehensive cover or back depends on the tariff. Ask for the terms and deadlines before signing.

What to do now

  1. Work out the current value of your vehicle and check whether leasing or financing requires collision cover.
  2. Decide what amount you could bear yourself after a claim and derive an excess from it.
  3. Compare terms, not only premiums: scope, workshop requirements, exclusions.
  4. Check discounts and the transfer of any existing no-claims class before you sign.

If you would like to go through your cover during your studies or early career with someone, you can find personal advice via Academycon.

Related guides

Sources: GDV model motor insurance terms AKB 2015, version 10.2017 (section A.2 own-damage cover, in German); ADAC, special termination right in motor insurance, page dated 2 November 2026 (in German).

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Gatekeeper model over 30: what it means for costs and fund choice

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Requesting a contribution certificate from your health insurer

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Fund merger or closure: what happens to contribution and membership