More info

Online Exams With Webcam: What Data Protection Allows

May a university monitor you by webcam or record your exam? This guide explains what data protection authorities and a court ruling say about online proctoring.
Zwei Studentinnen auf dem Campus im Herbst

Contents

An online exam with a webcam raises the question of how far a university may look into your living room. Data protection sets clear limits here, drawn from opinions of data protection authorities and from a court ruling. This guide summarises what the authorities and the court have said, what they rule out and where the legal position is still open.

Short answer: Webcam supervision during online exams is tightly limited under data protection law. In 2021 the state data protection commissioner of Baden-Württemberg, as one example from a single state, required voluntary participation, camera and microphone use only where strictly necessary, no room surveillance and no recording. In 2025 the Higher Regional Court of Thuringia (case no. 3 U 885/24) held that matching exam photos by facial recognition was processing of biometric data that is impermissible under Article 9 GDPR. Last updated: November 2026.

The most important points in brief

  • Webcam supervision must be limited to what the exam format strictly requires.
  • The Baden-Württemberg statement treats room surveillance and recording of the exam as impermissible.
  • The statement requires voluntary participation for exams held outside university premises.
  • According to the ruling of the Higher Regional Court of Thuringia (case no. 3 U 885/24), matching exam photos by facial recognition was impermissible in the case decided.
  • The legal bases are a matter for each German state, so a statement from one state does not automatically apply to your university.

Which limits the data protection authority set

The press release of the state data protection commissioner of Baden-Württemberg dated 14 April 2021 is one of the foundations of this guide. It names provisions of the state higher education act, created during the pandemic, as the legal basis. The authority stresses that online proctoring can severely restrict the rights of students and that supervision must not turn into total surveillance.

MeasurePosition of the sourceStatus
Taking part in online exams outside the universityMust be voluntary, for example through a parallel on-site optionPress release of 14.04.2021 (Baden-Württemberg)
Camera and microphoneActivate only where strictly required by the exam formatPress release of 14.04.2021 (Baden-Württemberg)
Room surveillanceMust not take placePress release of 14.04.2021 (Baden-Württemberg)
Recording of the examUnder no circumstances permissiblePress release of 14.04.2021 (Baden-Württemberg)
Biometric facial recognitionMatching exam photos by facial recognition impermissible in the case decided (Article 9 GDPR)Thuringia OLG ruling, 3 U 885/24 (report of 18.11.2025)

The press release also addresses software. A general check of the hardware or the transfer of stored data by software is not permitted according to it. The statements therefore work as a benchmark for proportionality, not as a complete list of permitted and prohibited cases.

What the Thuringia ruling means

The ruling of the Higher Regional Court of Thuringia (case no. 3 U 885/24, lower court Regional Court of Erfurt, 8 O 1117/22) concerns a university that used facial recognition in remote exams to match exam photos with a reference image. The court saw this as processing of biometric data under Article 4 No. 14 GDPR that was impermissible under Article 9(1) GDPR because neither explicit consent nor another exception under Article 9(2) GDPR applied. The plaintiff received 200 euros in non-material damages, the remainder of the claim failed and an appeal on points of law was not admitted. The court did not consider a transfer of the data to third countries proven, and the lockdown browser used was not in itself a data protection violation (copy of the ruling published by the Society for Civil Rights, in German, retrieved on 2 November 2026). The Society for Civil Rights (GFF) sees a signal effect beyond the individual case.

The ruling concerns the case decided, that is matching exam photos with a reference image by facial recognition. Whether other methods are permissible depends in each case on the General Data Protection Regulation, state law and the examination regulations. Read the decision itself before you draw a conclusion for your university.

What remains open

The ruling makes no separate statement on pure photography without biometrics. Whether a university may capture images without facial recognition depends on the examination regulations, state law and the GDPR in each case. There is no simple answer, and the question should be settled with the university directly.

What students can check

You do not have to carry the legal review alone, but a few questions before the exam clear up a lot. Find out which software the university uses, which data it processes and whether an on-site option exists.

  1. Read the examination regulations and the university notices on online exams.
  2. Ask in writing which software is used and what data it collects.
  3. Check whether an on-site option exists if you want to decline participation for data protection reasons.
  4. Document technical problems during the exam so that they can count as evidence.
  5. If you believe a breach occurred, a complaint to the data protection supervisory authority is an option.

Frequently asked questions

May the university record my online exam?

According to the 2021 statement of the state commissioner of Baden-Württemberg, under no circumstances. Whether other states or universities decide the same way depends on their state law and on your university. A ruling from one state cannot simply be transferred to another.

Must I agree to webcam supervision?

The statement requires voluntary participation for exams held outside university premises. A parallel on-site option can secure that. Ask the university how it implements this.

May the software analyse my face?

According to the ruling of the Higher Regional Court of Thuringia, matching exam photos by facial recognition was impermissible in the case decided because neither valid consent nor another exception under Article 9 GDPR applied. Whether this also applies beyond that case to your university cannot be derived reliably from a single ruling.

What about aids such as AI in the exam?

That is a different question from data protection. Which aids are allowed is set by the examination regulations. Our guide on AI in exams covers this.

Who is responsible if I want to complain?

A complaint goes to the data protection supervisory authority. Our guide on filing a data protection complaint explains the procedure and what to attach.

What to do with technical problems

If you run into technical problems during an exam, document the incident immediately. The university sets out in its regulations how an outage must be proven. Note the time, the error message and the device, and save screenshots where technically possible. How such proof counts is set by the university regulations. Our guide on technical problems in online exams describes this in detail.

So what do you do now?

  1. Ask the university which software is used and which data it processes.
  2. Check whether an on-site option exists and whether you can choose it.
  3. Ask which legal basis the university relies on.
  4. If you doubt the lawfulness, file a complaint with the competent data protection authority.

How to measure a form of surveillance

Four test questions follow from the statements of the data protection authority. They help you classify a concrete exam format, even if no ruling covers your exact case.

  • Is the surveillance strictly necessary for the exam format, or does it only serve the university’s convenience?
  • Does it capture more than image and sound during the exam, for example the whole room or content on your computer?
  • Is there an equivalent on-site alternative you can choose?
  • Are recordings stored, or does the supervision remain live without storage?

The more often these questions have to be answered with no, the closer the exam comes to the limits the authority named. A final assessment is not possible this way, because it depends on the examination regulations and on state law.

Why the legal position differs from state to state

Higher education acts regulate examinations differently in each German state. The Baden-Württemberg statement relies on provisions of the state higher education act that were created during the pandemic, namely sections 32a and 32b of that act. Whether your state has comparable rules is shown by its state law. For your university, its own examination regulations are also decisive.

The Thuringia ruling concerns one specific case at a university in that state. The Society for Civil Rights (GFF) sees a signal effect for other areas, such as surveillance at the workplace. That is the view of this organisation, not a statement of the court.

Questions to ask about exam software

If a university uses exam software, a short written list of questions is worth the effort. The points below cover the core of the data protection review.

  • Which data does the software collect, and how long is it stored?
  • Who has access to recordings, and to whom are they passed on?
  • Which legal basis does the processing rely on?
  • Is there a privacy notice for the exam software, and who is responsible for it?

The university should be able to give you these answers. If no answer comes, that is itself a reason to involve the university’s data protection officer before you take part in the exam.

Related reading

Sources: Press release of the state data protection commissioner of Baden-Württemberg on proctoring (14 April 2021). netzpolitik.org: biometric surveillance in online exams is unlawful (report of 18 November 2025 on the Thuringia OLG ruling). Copy of the ruling of the Higher Regional Court of Thuringia, case no. 3 U 885/24 (Society for Civil Rights, in German).

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Gatekeeper model over 30: what it means for costs and fund choice

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Requesting a contribution certificate from your health insurer

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Fund merger or closure: what happens to contribution and membership