More info

Green Power or Standard Tariff: What Really Pays Off

Green power or a standard tariff? How to read the electricity labelling under Section 42 EnWG, weigh origin against price and calculate the surcharge.
Zwei Studentinnen auf dem Campus im Herbst

Contents

Green power or a standard tariff: many students face this choice with their first own electricity contract, often without knowing what the label actually proves. Two questions matter. First, what the power costs. Second, what origin the electricity has according to the electricity labelling. This guide shows how to read both on your bill and how to weigh them against each other.

Kurz beantwortet: “Green power” is not a uniform product with one price. The decisive document is the electricity labelling under Section 42 EnWG, which suppliers must show on bills and their websites (last updated November 2026). Renewable energy only counts when guarantees of origin have been cancelled or when the power is reported under the Renewable Energy Sources Act (EEG). Whether the surcharge pays off depends on the price and term of the specific contract.

The most important points in brief

  • The word “green” in a tariff name says little, the labelling on the bill says more.
  • Suppliers must disclose the energy mix, including CO2 emissions and radioactive waste.
  • Guarantees of origin document where a quantity of power is accounted for, not automatically that a new plant was built.
  • A surcharge for green power makes most sense when origin matters to you and the extra cost stays manageable.
  • A standard tariff can be sensible when price and contract terms are your main criteria.

What the electricity labelling under Section 42 EnWG requires

Under Section 42 para. 1 EnWG, electricity suppliers must state the share of individual energy sources in the overall mix, on bills to final consumers, in advertising and on their website. The list includes nuclear power, coal, natural gas, other fossil sources and renewable energy with a guarantee of origin. The environmental impact must also be stated, at least the CO2 emissions and radioactive waste. The mix comes from the previous or the year before, and from 1 July of each year the figures of the preceding year apply.

The rule on recognising renewable energy is equally important. Under Section 42 para. 5 EnWG, renewables count as used only if the supplier relies on guarantees of origin that the responsible authority has cancelled under Section 79 para. 4 EEG, or if it reports EEG-supported electricity under the rules of the EEG. Renewables may also be shown as a share of the mix. The statute therefore determines which statements may count as green power at all.

How to read the labelling on your bill

The labelling is a plain list, not a sales brochure. The table below shows what to look for and what each entry means. The terms come from the statute, and the application in individual cases can be checked in the contract or with a consumer advice centre.

Entry on the billWhat it tells youWhat to check
Share of renewable energy in the mixDeclared share from renewable sourcesIs it backed by cancelled guarantees of origin?
Share of coal, natural gas or nuclear powerFossil and nuclear parts of the mixCompare with other tariffs from the same year
CO2 emissions per kilowatt hourEnvironmental impact in grams per kilowatt hourLower values mean lower emissions
Radioactive wasteWaste information for the mixMandatory entry, read it in comparison
Guarantees of origin from abroadProducing countries and their shareEspecially informative when support is absent

A comparison works best when both labellings come from the same reporting year. Otherwise you compare figures that cover different periods.

Weighing price against origin

The green-power surcharge is the central question in everyday life. Suppliers set different prices, and the contract term can change the comparison further. Do not calculate with an average from an advertisement. Use the energy price and base fee of the tariff you would actually sign.

Assumption for the following example: you consume 2,000 kilowatt hours a year. If the green tariff costs 2 cents more per kilowatt hour than the standard tariff, that is 40 euros more per year before base fees and bonuses are included. Whether that amount is worth the origin to you is your decision. Confirm the real prices with the supplier, because they change.

  1. Take your annual consumption from the last statement.
  2. Note the energy price and base fee of both tariffs for the same term.
  3. Compare the electricity labelling of both suppliers, ideally from the same reporting year.
  4. Calculate the extra cost in euros per year and check it against your budget.

When green power adds real value

Real added value arises mainly when the tariff relies on demonstrable renewable quantities and the statements under Section 42 EnWG are traceable. Many students choose green power because climate protection matters to them. A guarantee of origin, however, documents a quantity in the balance. It does not guarantee that a new plant was built in your region. Anyone who wants to support expansion should ask for offers that explicitly report investments in new plants.

When the standard tariff is the better choice

A standard tariff makes sense when your budget is tight and you do not value the origin. It can also fit when you share a flat and any change must be agreed with others. In both cases the labelling must still be present and understandable, because it belongs to every supply contract.

Frequently asked questions

Is green power automatically more climate-friendly?

Not necessarily. The energy mix and the CO2 emissions show whether a tariff is climate-friendly. The name alone says little. Check whether renewable energy is backed by cancelled guarantees of origin or reported under the EEG.

How do I tell whether renewables are properly documented?

Under Section 42 para. 5 EnWG the guarantees of origin must be cancelled by the responsible authority under Section 79 para. 4 EEG, or the power must be reported under the EEG. On the bill this usually appears as a share of the mix. If no reference exists at all, ask the supplier in writing.

Can I switch a green tariff easily?

Switching depends on the term and the notice period of the existing contract. Check whether a bonus or a price guarantee is tied to the term. The guide on dynamic electricity tariffs covers price adjustments and what they mean for your choice.

Am I obliged to choose green power?

No. The labelling rules prescribe how suppliers must present information. They do not oblige you to pick a particular tariff. What matters is that the information is complete and can be checked.

What to do now

  1. Check the electricity labelling on your last bill and note the renewable share.
  2. Compare two or three tariffs with the same term and the same annual consumption.
  3. Ask in writing for proof of renewable energy if anything is unclear.
  4. Then decide whether the surcharge is worth the origin to you.

Related guides

Sources: Section 42 EnWG, gesetze-im-internet.de, retrieved November 2026; Section 41a EnWG, gesetze-im-internet.de, retrieved November 2026

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Gatekeeper model over 30: what it means for costs and fund choice

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Requesting a contribution certificate from your health insurer

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Fund merger or closure: what happens to contribution and membership