A warning letter over third-party photos often arrives without warning. An image from a search engine, a picture from a friend’s feed or a portrait you used on your blog can be enough, and suddenly a letter with demands is in your inbox. Two different rights sit behind this issue and you should keep them apart: the copyright in the photo and the personality right of the person shown. This guide explains what a warning letter (Abmahnung) means in German law, how to check it and which responses make sense.
Short answer: A warning letter asks you to stop an infringement and to refrain from it in future. It usually demands a cease-and-desist declaration backed by a contractual penalty. You do not have to sign it immediately. First check whether the letter contains the details required by section 97a (2) of the German Copyright Act (UrhG), who created the photo and whether a person can be recognised. For private individuals without commercial use, the lawyer’s fee claim is capped at a value in dispute of 1,000 euros (Last updated: November 2026).
The most important points at a glance
- A warning letter is a request to stop an infringement. It is meant to settle the dispute without a lawsuit.
- A photo can be protected on two levels: the copyright of the photographer and the rights of the person shown.
- A valid warning letter must be clear and name the infringement precisely. If it does not, the law treats it as invalid.
- For private individuals without commercial use, the reimbursable lawyer’s fees are capped at a value in dispute of 1,000 euros.
- Signing the cease-and-desist declaration too quickly can be expensive, so check it first.
What does a warning letter actually do?
A warning letter is an out-of-court demand to end a specific conduct and not to repeat it. Under section 97a (1) UrhG, the injured party should send a warning before filing an action for an injunction and give the other side the chance to settle the dispute with a cease-and-desist declaration that carries an appropriate contractual penalty. The letter is therefore primarily an offer to settle, not a court decision. Whether the claim is justified depends on the specific circumstances.
A typical letter contains three elements: the allegation of an infringement, a pre-formulated cease-and-desist declaration and a demand for payment covering legal fees and often damages. The declaration matters most, because it binds you for the future. If you infringe again, the agreed contractual penalty can become due.
Which rights are at stake with photos online?
With third-party photos you should answer two questions separately. The first concerns the author: who took the photo, and did they permit this use? The second concerns the person: is someone recognisably shown, and did they consent? The table below shows typical situations.
| Situation | Right concerned | Question to ask |
|---|---|---|
| Photo from a picture agency or photographer without a suitable licence | Copyright (UrhG) | Does a licence cover exactly your use? |
| Portrait of a recognisable person in a blog or post | Right to one’s own image (KunstUrhG) | Did the person shown consent? |
| Person only visible as incidental background | Right to one’s own image with exceptions | Does an exception under section 23 KunstUrhG apply? |
Under section 22 sentence 1 of the Act on Copyright in Works of Visual Arts (KunstUrhG), images may only be distributed or publicly displayed with the consent of the person depicted. Consent is presumed in case of doubt if the person received payment for being photographed. A post with a person in the foreground therefore usually falls under this rule. Exceptions are set out in section 23 KunstUrhG and need to be checked case by case. For how to publish your own photos of others, see Right to your own image: when you may post photos of others.
How do you check a warning letter step by step?
Do not react on the first impulse. A warning letter is only effective if it meets the requirements of section 97a (2) UrhG. It must state clearly and understandably the name or company of a representative, describe the infringement precisely, itemise the payment claims and say whether the proposed cease-and-desist declaration goes significantly beyond the infringement. A letter that does not meet these requirements is invalid under the law. Whether the claim itself then falls away depends on the individual case, which a specialist should clarify.
- Note which photo was online, where and since when, and save screenshots with dates.
- Check whether the letter describes the alleged infringement concretely. Vague wording is a warning sign.
- Review the payment demand and the breakdown of each item.
- Compare the proposed cease-and-desist declaration with the actual infringement. If it goes far beyond it, that is a separate point to examine.
- Get a legal assessment before signing or paying, especially if the amount or the contractual penalty is high.
What does a warning letter cost?
Costs are the point that worries most recipients. Under section 97a (3) UrhG, the reimbursement of lawyer’s fees for a justified warning is limited to a value in dispute of 1,000 euros where the recipient is a private individual without commercial or self-employed professional use and there is no existing cease-and-desist obligation. This caps the calculation basis rather than setting a flat fee. What the claim finally amounts to depends on the fee rules and the circumstances, so a check before payment is worthwhile.
The reverse also applies. If the warning is unjustified or invalid, you can claim reimbursement of your defence costs under section 97a (4) UrhG, unless the sender could not have recognised the lack of entitlement. You must assert this claim yourself. It does not arise automatically just because you ignored the letter.
Which response makes sense?
The right response depends on whether the infringement actually occurred. The overview below helps with the decision but does not replace an assessment of your case.
| Response | Advantage | Risk |
|---|---|---|
| Silence | Signing a declaration does not happen by itself | The sender can file a lawsuit and raise the costs |
| Remove the photo and reply factually | Shows willingness to talk and limits the dispute | A cease-and-desist declaration may still be demanded |
| Sign the cease-and-desist declaration | The dispute is often ended quickly | A contractual penalty applies to future violations |
| Professional review before any declaration | Clarifies validity, amount and alternatives | The advice itself costs money |
Frequently asked questions
May I use a photo from the internet if I name the source?
Naming the source does not usually replace permission. The quotation right under section 51 UrhG applies only where the use is justified by the purpose of the quotation, for example to explain a content. A purely decorative picture in a post usually does not fall under it. Naming the source is polite and helps clarify matters, but it does not justify the use.
Do I have to answer a warning letter within a fixed deadline?
Many letters set a deadline of a few days or weeks. Whether such a deadline is legally binding has to be checked case by case. You should still not ignore it, because a short reply can prevent court proceedings.
Is it enough to delete the photo after the warning?
Deleting the photo ends the infringement for the future and is an important step. It does not automatically settle costs or damages for the past. Address these points in a written response or with advice.
Does this also apply if I posted the picture only privately?
For the right to one’s own image, it often matters whether a picture is distributed or publicly displayed, because section 22 KunstUrhG regulates exactly that. Sharing with a small closed group may therefore be assessed differently from a public post. There is no blanket answer.
What if the sender does not clearly act as the rights holder?
A warning letter must name the representative of the claimant. Check these details carefully. If the letter does not clearly describe the infringement, it is invalid under section 97a (2) UrhG. A factual question asking for proof of rights is a sensible first step.
What to do now
- Secure all documents: the letter, the photos with their location and date, and your previous correspondence.
- Check the formal requirements under section 97a (2) UrhG and whether the infringement is named concretely.
- Remove the disputed photo if you cannot rule out an infringement, and note the date.
- Obtain a professional assessment before signing or paying, especially for high demands or a high contractual penalty.
- Reply factually and on time, without admitting fault and without threats.
Related reading
- Digital rights in everyday life: the overview for students
- Right to your own image: when you may post photos of others
- Filesharing warning letter: what students should do now
- Sharing lecture notes and slides: what copyright allows in study
- Creative Commons: using images legally and attributing them correctly
Sources: Section 97a UrhG, warning letter (gesetze-im-internet.de, German); Section 22 KunstUrhG, images (gesetze-im-internet.de, German); Section 51 UrhG, quotations (gesetze-im-internet.de, German).
Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.