More info

Adjusting Your Utility Advance Payment: When to Lower It

Adjusting your utility advance payment: under § 560(4) BGB you can lower the instalment after a statement of accounts in text form. Example, steps and exceptions.
Zwei Studentinnen auf dem Campus im Herbst

Contents

Adjusting your advance payment for utilities does not require an agreement with your landlord, only a declaration in text form and a statement of accounts as a basis. That is what § 560(4) of the Bürgerliches Gesetzbuch (BGB, German Civil Code) provides. For students on a tight budget it is worth checking whether the monthly instalment is set too high, because a credit at the end of the year is an interest-free loan to the landlord. This guide shows when you can lower the instalment, how to calculate it and what applies to halls of residence and shared flats.

Short answer: Under § 560(4) BGB, after a statement of accounts either party can set the agreed advance payments for operating costs (Betriebskosten) at a reasonable amount by a declaration in text form. The law gives no formula for the amount. In student halls of residence the provision does not apply under § 549(3) BGB. Last updated: November 2026.

The key points at a glance

  • Adjustment requires that advance payments were agreed and a statement of accounts exists (§ 560(4) BGB).
  • Both sides can ask for it: you in case of a credit, the landlord in case of a back payment.
  • The wording requires a declaration in text form and names no consent from the other side.
  • A flat-rate payment follows different rules, in § 560(1) and (3) BGB, and agreements to the tenant’s disadvantage are void.
  • In student halls of residence §§ 556d to 561 BGB do not apply under § 549(3), your contract governs.

What does § 560(4) BGB say about adjusting the advance payment?

If you and your landlord have agreed advance payments for operating costs, after a statement of accounts either party can set the advance payments at a reasonable amount by a declaration in text form. This applies to increases and reductions alike. The legislator thereby created a one-sided way of bringing the instalment closer to actual costs without having to change the tenancy agreement. The wording is available at gesetze-im-internet.de (German).

Paragraph 5 requires the principle of economic efficiency to be observed when operating costs change. Paragraph 6 declares void any agreement that departs from § 560 to the tenant’s disadvantage. A tenancy agreement therefore cannot validly forbid you to adjust.

When can you lower the instalment, and when can the landlord raise it?

The statement of accounts is decisive. If it shows a credit, the advance payment was above actual costs and you can set a lower instalment. If it shows a back payment, the landlord can raise the instalment. Without a statement, paragraph 4 does not provide for adjustment, because it expressly links to a previous statement of accounts.

SituationWho can adjustBasis
Advance payment agreed, statement shows a creditYou can set a lower instalment§ 560(4) BGB
Advance payment agreed, statement shows a back paymentThe landlord can set a higher instalment§ 560(4) BGB
Flat-rate payment, costs riseThe landlord may pass on increases proportionally if the contract provides for it§ 560(1) BGB
Flat-rate payment, costs fallThe flat rate must be reduced accordingly and the landlord must tell you without delay§ 560(3) BGB
Place in a student hall of residence§ 560 BGB does not apply, the contract counts§ 549(3) BGB

How do you work out a reasonable advance payment?

The law gives no formula and speaks of a reasonable amount. An obvious aid is the total actual cost from the last statement of accounts divided by twelve. If prices have changed noticeably since the accounting period, that can be taken into account. What is reasonable remains an assessment in the individual case.

Assumption (fictitious values)Credit exampleBack-payment example
Advance payment per month90 euros70 euros
Advance payment per year1,080 euros840 euros
Actual costs per statement888 euros1,032 euros
Result of the statementCredit of 192 eurosBack payment of 192 euros
Aid: costs divided by twelve74 euros per month86 euros per month

In the first example the current instalment is 16 euros above the figure from the aid, in the second 16 euros below it. The numbers are freely chosen and only show the calculation. Your statement may contain other items, such as heating costs that depend on consumption.

How do you word the declaration?

The wording requires text form, so you can give the declaration by e-mail or letter, for example. Keep it short and clear. Name the statement of accounts you rely on, the amount of the old and the new advance payment and the month from which the new amount should apply. Paragraph 4 does not expressly say when the adjustment takes effect. If the landlord objects, ask a tenants’ association.

  • Reference to the operating-cost statement with the accounting period.
  • Reference to § 560(4) BGB as the basis.
  • Old and new monthly advance payment in euros.
  • Start of the new instalment.
  • Date and sender, so that receipt can be proven.

What applies to shared flats, subletting and halls of residence?

If you are the main tenant, § 560 BGB applies in your relationship with your landlord. If you live as a subtenant, adjustment depends on your sublease. In a student hall of residence, § 549(3) BGB declares §§ 556d to 561 inapplicable. Utilities are set out in the contract with the student services organisation or provider. How costs in halls are made up is explained in the guide on hall costs. In a flat share with several main tenants, agree among yourselves before anyone gives the declaration.

Frequently asked questions

Can the landlord raise the advance payment?

Yes, if advance payments were agreed and a statement of accounts shows a back payment. Under § 560(4) BGB he can set the advance payments at a reasonable amount by a declaration in text form.

Does the landlord have to agree to a reduction?

The wording requires a declaration in text form and names no consent from the other side. The amount must be reasonable. If the landlord considers it unreasonable, a dispute can arise, which you can clarify with a tenants’ association if necessary.

Can I simply pay less?

Paragraph 4 provides for the route of a declaration in text form. If you transfer less without one, you risk arrears. Give the declaration first and document its receipt.

What applies to a flat-rate payment?

For a flat rate the rules of § 560(1) to (3) BGB apply. The landlord may pass on increases only if the contract provides for it, and he must reduce the flat rate when costs fall.

Can the tenancy agreement exclude adjustment?

Under § 560(6) BGB an agreement to the tenant’s disadvantage is void. A clause denying you adjustment therefore does not help the landlord.

What to do now

  1. Find your last operating-cost statement and check it for accuracy.
  2. Compare actual costs with your advance payments and work out the new monthly instalment.
  3. Give your declaration in text form, referring to the statement, the new amount and the start date.
  4. Document the date and receipt and keep the statement and declaration on file.
  5. Apply the new instalment only after clarifying with the landlord, and take advice from a tenants’ association in case of dispute.

Related guides

Sources: Civil Code (BGB), § 560 changes in operating costs (gesetze-im-internet.de, retrieved November 2026, German text); Civil Code (BGB), § 549 provisions applicable to residential tenancies (gesetze-im-internet.de, retrieved November 2026, German text).

Last updated: November 2026. This guide is general information, not individual advice.

Teilen

Weitere Artikel

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Gatekeeper model over 30: what it means for costs and fund choice

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Requesting a contribution certificate from your health insurer

Student vergleicht am Schreibtisch zwei Versichertenkarten

Fund merger or closure: what happens to contribution and membership